Sweater Election

So on facebook (before I ditched fb--over 2 weeks ago!), I had a bunch of people vote from a select few striped sweaters that I liked. When I went to buy the sweat that won, it was sold out of my size. :(

Here is a creepy and poorly done photoshop of me in the sweater for you to imagine the potential joy I was denied.

 

 Here is a sweater I bought instead in order to try on and potentially keep. the armpits and shoulders are really big, so it's going back.

Here is another sweater I actually bought. It's comfortable and soft, so I will probably keep it.

This is the sweater that in appearances I loved the most. Actual physical comfort in this sweater leaves something to be desired. I felt like it was too short and worried that it might shrink. I will probably return it for a bigger size.

 

Your thoughts on the sweaters? Which do you like best? I should really only keep one.